
Iowa’s A Long Way From Idaho
August 31, 2007Vermont and Massachusetts, you rock! At least you’ve taken a stab at providing equal rights to gays and lesbians! Civil Unions and even marriage have been happenin’ all over the place in those diminutive in size, but large in heart, states. Funny, the predictions of rampant chaos have proven groundless and the ability of straight people to live their own family values has not been impinged. The Union has not crumbled. California has been struggling for years to make our situation out here a little more equitable, and we are supposedly the most liberal of leftie states. Thing is, until we have a Federal recognition of our unions, any strides made out here regarding our “domestic partnership” situation out here in California and elsewhere will never make for a level playing field.
So, what happened today? Another little victory was won, via an obscure district court judge in the fine, diminutive state of Iowa (population 3 million). I received this from my good friend Red Hog:
BREAKING NEWS: Judge in Polk County, Iowa Rules in Favor of Gay Marriage
ASSOCIATED PRESS
August 30, 2007
A Polk County judge on Thursday struck down Iowa’s law banning gay marriage.
The ruling by Judge Robert Hanson concluded that the state’s prohibition on same-sex marriage is unconstitutional and he ordered the Polk County recorder to issue marriage licenses to six gay couples.
“This is kind of the American Dream,” said plaintiff Jen BarbouRoske, of Iowa City. “I’m still feeling kind of shaky. It’s pure elation, I just cannot believe it.”
Camilla Taylor, an attorney with Lambda Legal, a New York-based gay rights organization, said the ruling requires “full equality for all Iowans including gay and lesbian Iowans and their families.”
“The Iowa Constitution has lived up to its promises of equality for everyone,” she said.
Gay couples from anywhere in Iowa could apply for a marriage license from Polk County. The process takes three days, however.
Polk County is expected to appeal the ruling to the Iowa Supreme Court.
County Attorney John Sarcone said the county would immediately seek a stay from Hanson, which if granted would prevent anyone from seeking a marriage license until an appeal could be heard.
The case will be appealed to the Iowa Supreme Court, which could refer it to the Iowa Court of Appeals, consider the case itself or decide not to hear the case.
Des Moines lawyer Dennis Johnson represented the six gay couples who filed suit after they were denied marriage licenses. He called the ruling “a moral victory for equal rights.”…more
WHOA! That’s where I was raised! But, guess what – something you may not know about Iowa is that it’s pretty much split down the middle Donkey/Pachyderm. One side of the state is full of college towns and industrial centers and the other side is primarily agriculture. Iowa is not full of hicks. Iowans are as politically sophisticated as I’ve seen anywhere in the country. These are the same people who voted for the amendment. But, times, and opinions change and now is the time to undo the damage done. Polk County is also home of the state capital, Des Moines (silent “s” people, not Dez Moinz). The state was split by less than 1% on the reelection of the Shrub.
Republicans are screaming, “It’s the will of the people and shouldn’t be determined outside the legislature or popular vote.” The Shrub is leading by example and the Iowa Republicans have been watching, as strides are made to disembowel the judicial branch’s ability to look at the law on its own merits if it doesn’t conform nicely with his agenda. Let’s hope that doesn’t happen. That’s what the courts are there for—to interpret the law, regardless of what some hyped up power hungry politician says (on either side of the spectrum).
The Iowa Supremes are at a crossroads. They can rule, as they should, that denying marital rights to same sex couples via constitutional amendment, is unlawful. Or, they can put Iowa back with all those other suck states full of voters who think it’s okay to decide how people like me live their lives, while they get to live theirs any old way they want. I hope the BarbouRoske’s and the other plaintiffs prevail.
The most successful marriages, gay or straight, even if they begin in romantic love, often become friendships. It’s the ones that become the friendships that last. ~ Andrew Sullivan






